Posts tagged ‘MRC’

January 20, 2013

A River Trickles Through It: Laos’ Mekong Dam Draws Ire From Downstream Neighbors And Environmentalists

POLITICS:

A River Trickles Through It: Laos’ Mekong Dam Draws Ire From Downstream Neighbors And Environmentalists

Click on the link to get more news and video from original source: http://www.ibtimes.com/river-trickles-through-it-laos-mekong-dam-draws-ire-downstream-neighbors-environmentalists-1026360

BY Ryan Villarreal | January 19 2013 9:27 AM

Laos’ construction of a hydropower dam on the Mekong River has angered its downstream neighbors and raised concerns about the project’s social and environmental impacts.

Construction of the $3.5 billion Xayaburi Dam began last November. It is the first of 11 projects the Laotian government plans to build along the lower portion of the river, which passes through Cambodia, Vietnam and Thailand.

Laos has drawn criticism from its Southeast Asian neighbors for beginning construction on the Xayaburi Dam without completing the consultation process through the Mekong River Commission, or MRC, an inter-governmental agency comprised of representatives from the four countries that manages the usage and development of the river.

Vietnam’s Deputy Minister of Natural Resources and Environment Hong Ha Tran spoke Wednesday at an MRC Council Meeting in Luang Prabang, Laos, and he questioned the wisdom of beginning the Xayaburi project before a thorough analysis of its impact was completed.

The launching of the first mainstream hydropower project recently in the Lower Mekong Basin is causing concerns of the governments of the riparian [river-adjacent] countries in the region and the international community about its adverse impacts on downstream areas,” he said.

“While we are still trying to do the research to understand its impacts, each riparian country should show their responsibility by assuring that any future development and management of water resources proposed in the basin should be considered with due care and full precaution based on best scientific understanding of the potential impacts,” he added.

Vietnam has demanded that Laos halt construction on the Xayaburi dam, pending the completion of an environmental impact review agreed upon by the MRC in December 2011.

The MRC Development Partners, which is comprised of donor governments — including the U.S., Japan, Germany and France — that have invested in the Mekong River’s management, released a joint statement expressing concern about any damming of the river’s main channel, upon which the Xayaburi damn is being built.

“It is our consensus that building dams on the mainstream of the Mekong may irrevocably change the river and hence constitute a challenge for food security, sustainable development and biodiversity conservation,” the statement read, according to a press release from International Rivers, a global NGO that advocates for the conservation and sustainable development of river systems.

Extensive research has already shown that dams are extremely disruptive to river ecosystems and riparian communities on multiple levels.

Damming prevents fish migrations, which downstream communities depend on for food. It also prevents rivers from transporting sediments, “which are critical for maintaining physical processes and habitats downstream of the dam (including the maintenance of productive deltas, barrier islands, fertile floodplains and coastal wetlands),” according to International Rivers.

This has negative implications for farmland and fresh water wells used by communities along river systems.

While these impacts are being considered with the Xayaburi Dam, Laos is relatively free to continue construction unhindered. Under the statutes of the MRC, Laos is obligated to hold consultations with member governments on such projects, but members have no legal framework to prevent it from moving forward with any given one.

“In the absence of an agreement, other countries can disagree if they like, but this can’t stop Laos,” said Jian-hua Meng, a specialist in sustainable hydropower at the World Wildlife Fund, the Guardian reported. “The role of the MRC is now being questioned along with the level of investment put in the organization.”

November 6, 2012

Laos to begin building hotly debated Xayaburi dam this week

Laos to begin building hotly debated Xayaburi dam this week

Click on the link to get more news and video from original source:  http://latimesblogs.latimes.com/world_now/2012/11/laos-to-begin-building-hotly-debated-dam-this-week.html

November 6, 2012 |  4:45 am

Laos plans to start building a dam on the Mekong River this week, a step that neighboring Cambodia and Vietnam fear could imperil fish and cripple rice fields.

The Xayaburi dam is expected to reap profits for Laos by generating hydropower to sell to Thailand. The $3-billion-plus project would be the first major dam on the lower part of the Mekong, a massive waterway that provides food and jobs to millions of people in Southeast Asia.

Building the dam marks the latest push toward development for Laos, a growing economy seeking to shed its “least developed country” label. The communist country has opened up its economy over the last few decades and was recently accepted into the World Trade Organization.

“Hydropower is a big natural advantage for Laos,” Deputy Minister of Energy and Mining Viraphonh Viravong told Bloomberg on Monday.

But Vietnam and Cambodia worry dams could endanger fish that families eat and hurt crops in the Mekong Delta, the “rice bowl” of the region. Environmental experts warn if fish dwindle and croplands are lost, damming the river could cost more than it brings in. A Portland State University study last year estimated losses could run as high as $274 billion if a passel of planned dams are built.

A regional report recommended waiting for more studies to assess the dangers, but Laos has pressed ahead.

“They are playing roulette with the Mekong River,” said Ame Trandem, Southeast Asia program director for International Rivers. “There are serious risks for the river and the people who depend on it.”

Laos says it addressed those concerns in the design of its dam, using special features that allow migrating fish to pass through. But Trandem and other environmentalists say those strategies are unlikely to work in the Mekong, populated by some of the biggest fish in the world.

Under an agreement struck 17 years ago, Laos is supposed to consult with Vietnam, Cambodia and Thailand on damming the whole river, under the shared Mekong River Commission. The Laotian government has reportedly argued the agreement doesn’t apply in this case. The decision to build the Xayaburi dam appears to flout the pact.

There was no immediate reaction from Cambodia or Vietnam when Laos announced its plans Monday. Thailand, which is hungry for new sources of power, has agreed to buy the electricity, though a group of Thai villagers are suing their government over the plans and protested on the river Monday.

The news went out the same day that a meeting of European and Asian leaders opened in Laos, a surprise to Southeast Asia watchers who had expected the issue to be hashed out during the summit this week. The way the region reacts could spell out the future of the Mekong.

“This is the opening of Pandora’s box,” said Nathanial Matthews, a hydropower researcher at King’s College London. “Unless there is real pushback in the next six months, I see Laos moving ahead quite quickly with the rest of the dams.”

Eleven dams are planned for the lower Mekong. The next test will be whether Laos follows the same path in pursuing the next project, or whether it bends to neighbors’ concerns. One expert said Xayaburi might have been a unique case because lots of money had already been sunk into preparing the site.

“They could still do it right for the next one,” consulting neighbors and paying attention to their worries, said Richard P. Cronin, director of the Southeast Asia Program at the Stimson Center. “But if they build all of these dams, that will be the coup de grace for the Mekong Delta.”

August 27, 2012

Mekong panel didn’t approve power deal

Click on the link to get more news and video from original source:  http://www.nationmultimedia.com/opinion/Mekong-panel-didnt-approve-power-deal-30189116.html

-

Mekong panel didn’t approve power deal

August 27, 2012 1:00 am

Ref: “Xayaburi hydro project on schedule, Energy Ministry says”, Business, August 25.

I am writing to correct misleading statements in the article on the references to the Mekong River Commission.

The article says the power purchase agreement for the hydropower project has been signed by Egat and the developer and approved by the Mekong River Commission (MRC). I would like to clarify that the MRC does not and cannot approve any power purchase agreements for hydropower development projects proposed by its member countries. Consideration and approval of such agreements, project financing and other business aspects do not fall under the MRC’s role and responsibilities.

The MRC is not a regulatory or supranational body. As a regional, inter-governmental body, the role of the MRC in the prior consultation process for the proposed Xayaburi hydropower project is to facilitate regional dialogue and provide technical input and advice for the discussion on risks and benefits of such projects. We provide a platform for member countries to raise their concerns on, for example, impacts of the project on the livelihoods of the people and the environment and sustainability of the project. Through MRC the member countries can raise these concerns and work together to address issues of common interest.

The article also says the Laotian government suspended project construction on the Mekong but allowed inland work based on the MRC’s advice. I would like to clarify that the Lao delegation has informed other MRC member countries that the construction at the project site is the preparatory and exploratory work, not the construction of the dam itself. Laos has not stated that there was ongoing construction of the dam on the Mekong.

Hans Guttman

CEO, Mekong River Commission Secretariat

Vientiane

August 17, 2012

Laos never ordered work on Xayaburi Dam to stop: Official

Click on the link to get more news and video from original source:  http://www.mizzima.com/news/regional/7788-laos-never-ordered-work-on-xayaburi-dam-to-stop-official.html

Friday, 17 August 2012 14:51, Mizzima News

The construction site of the Xayaburi Dam on the Mekong River in Laos.
Photo: International Rivers / flickr

The Thai developer of the US$ 3.5 billion Xayaburi hydropower dam in Laos says the Laotian government never sent a formal letter asking it to stop construction of the dam, which has prompted  serious concerns from Cambodia and Vietnam that it will damage the ecology and livlihood of the region.

On July 13, the Laotian government said work had stopped after neighbors’ Cambodia and Vietnam said the 1,285-megawatt dam would harm the economy along the river and damage the fishery, which is heavily relied upon as a food source.

“We are still working on the project. We haven’t received a formal letter from the Lao government that we should suspend or put the project on hold,” Plew Trivisvavet, the chief executive Officer at Thailand’s Ch Karnchang Pcl, told reporters, according to a Reuters news agency article on Thursday.

The government of Laos made no immediate comment regarding the report.

The dam would be the first along the main stream of the Mekong in Southeast Asia.

The Mekong River Commission, comprising Cambodia, Laos, Thailand and Vietnam, have said that member governments agreed to approach the Japanese government and other international development partners to further study the dam’s implications before giving Laos the go-ahead to continue construction.

Plew said Ch Karnchang, the dam’s main contractor, expects to begin construction of a reservoir at the site later this year. “We have entered the area for some relocation work and to prepare for the construction of the reservoir,” he said.

Meanwhile, the Vietnam News Service (VNS) on Thursday said Vietnamese experts have again called for a moratorium on dam building on the Mekong River, saying the lives of as many as 60 million people could be adversely impacted by the dams.

Two key economic sectors in Vietnam’s fertile Mekong Delta, would suffer critical losses in rice and seafood production, said conservationists.

Dr. Dao Trong Tu, a former member of the Viet Nam Mekong River Committee, said the river runs across six countries, and that dams on its upper reaches would have harmful impacts on a vast area of the river basin.

Daniel King, Southeast Asia Legal Director of Earth Rights International, said there was a need to strengthen regional institutions to improve implementation of a common legal framework on exploitation of the river, according to VNS.

“In addition to making findings and recommendations on the environmental and social impacts of the 11 dams, the Mekong River Committee should identify critical shortcomings that should be addressed prior to any dam construction on mainstream Mekong,” he said.

It is the first of 11 dams planned in the lower Mekong that are projected to generate 8 percent of energy-hungry Southeast Asia’s power by 2025.

The proposed 11 dams would turn 55 per cent of the river into reservoirs, resulting in estimated agricultural losses of more than $500 million a year and cutting the average protein intake of Thai and Lao people by 30 per cent, according to a study by the Mekong River Commission.

China has completed four dams on the upper river, closer to its source. Activists say they were responsible for a 2010 drought that sent lower Mekong water levels to their lowest in half a century.

Ch Karnchang’s 50 per cent-owned subsidiary, Xayaburi Power Co, has received a 29-year concession contract from the Laotian government to operate the dam’s power plant.

Xayaburi Power said it will sell the power to state-run Electricity Generating Authority of Thailand, the country’s sole power distributor, in 2019, Plew said, adding Ch Karnchang anticipated revenue of about 4 billion baht ($127 million) from the project this year.

Related News:

April 24, 2012

Xayaburi study locks in funding

Click on the link to get more news and video from original source:  http://www.phnompenhpost.com/index.php/2012042355715/National-news/xayaburi-study-locks-in-funding.html

Shane Worrell

Monday, 23 April 2012

Local villagers stand on the banks of the Mekong River in Xayaburi province, Laos, near the area where a controversial dam is slated for construction. Photo by International Rivers

Japan has agreed to fund a study into what negative effects the controversial Xayaburi hydro dam project in Laos could have on Mekong River communities, a Cambodia National Mekong Committee official said yesterday.

Te Navuth, the committee’s secretary-general, said Mekong River Commission (MRC) member states, including Cambodia, had agreed in December that another study was needed before the 1,260-megawatt dam project could begin.

“Mekong countries and Japan have agreed to carry out this study,” he said, referring to discussions at the Japan-Mekong Summit in Tokyo over the weekend. “Before, we didn’t have this statement clearly.”

Thai development firm Ch.Karnchang announced it had begun construction work on the dam on March 15 after signing a US$2.4 billion contract with the Xayaburi Power Company, the Post reported last week.

Sin Niny, permanent vice-chairman of CNMC, was reported elsewhere saying Cambodia had the right to file a legal complaint if Laos began the project on its own.

Under a 1995 agreement, a host country must consult MRC members of such projects before proceeding.

Te Navuth said legal action against Laos might be hasty.

“I don’t think [Cambodia] would do this. [The agreement with Japan] is a new positive development . . . that will promote cooperation of the member states.”

But concern remained over whether the dam project, the first of its kind on the Lower Mekong, had begun, he said.

“We have reports of some preliminary constructions,” Te Navuth said. “Cambodia will send an official to Laos. We have sent several letters . . . [asking them] not to proceed with any work. I think they will consider this [new study],” he said, adding they had been unresponsive in the past.

Save the Mekong spokesperson Meach Mean said he was concerned about the project.

“Without a study, we do not know what … the damage will be,” he said. “We ask the Lao government to postpone [the dam project]. Please, Laos, respect the 1995 agreement.”

Sin Niny and the Japanese Embassy in Phnom Penh could not be reached.


To contact the reporter on this story: Shane Worrell at shane.worrell@phnompenhpost.com

 

Related News:

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 236 other followers

%d bloggers like this: