Experts wonder whether one of the least-developed nations in the world can properly manage a huge influx of money from neighbors aiming to extend their territory
View Original Source: http://www.taipeitimes.com/News/biz/archives/2011/05/22/2003503822
By Amelie Bottollier-Depois /
AFP, BOTEN, LAOS. The language is Chinese, change is given in yuan and the time is set for Beijing — but the Boten casino is in Laos, not China.
This impoverished country is overrun by investments from the more powerful neighbors that surround it and is struggling to impose a development strategy.
The casino and garishly colored hotels have been developed in Boten over the past five years, against a backdrop of mountains a stone’s throw from the Chinese border.
Laotians are not welcome in this Chinese-controlled new town, which is far from the only example of China’s widespread presence in this landlocked communist country of about 6 million people.
The Chinese projects are on a large scale — mines, dams, a high-speed rail project, agricultural concessions — and have led to concerns in the small nation.
“The Chinese presence is on everyone’s lips. It’s a subject which Laotians have started to talk about increasingly overtly and more critically,” a Laos-based foreign expert said.
China, and also Vietnam and Thailand, “use Laos as an extension of their territory,” said Dominique Van der Borght, of Oxfam Belgium in the Laotian capital, Vientiane.
Long reliant on foreign aid, Laos is now the subject of massive foreign investment. According to official figures, the inflows rose from US$51 million in 2001 to US$13.6 billion last year, led by the three neighboring countries with more than US$8 billion last year.
Those figures can only rise further with the announcement of new projects including the country’s first full-length railway, from Boten to Vientiane.
Construction of the US$7 billion line, largely financed by Chinese firms, has not yet begun, but plans call for completion by 2015.
At first glance Laos, one of the world’s poorest nations, should welcome this investment.
However, Rio Pals, coordinator of INGO Network which groups more than 70 humanitarian organizations in Laos, expressed concern about the government’s ability to properly manage the huge influx of money.
“They don’t have the capacity at this moment to check at the door whether it is quality investment,” she said.
Laos officially grew at 7.9 percent between 2006 and last year, an expansion largely founded on exploitation of natural resources in the country, which has no industrial output.
“Forests, agricultural land, water and hydropower potential, and mineral resources comprise more than half the country’s total wealth,” a World Bank report said.
Care must be taken “not to saw off the branch on which Laos sits,” the foreign expert said.
Laos is a rural-based society and some experts fear that its people, who depend on the country’s forests and waters for sustenance, are paying for their country’s growth model.
Pals said the country’s goal of advancing from least-developed nation status by 2020 might be affected unless there is a system to ensure good-quality investments that benefit the entire population.
Some analysts, though, say the 2020 target seems reachable. At its five-yearly congress in March the ruling communist party confirmed this aim of escaping the ranks of the world’s 48 poorest countries.
“The bet is not impossible to win” given recent economic growth rates, said Vatthana Pholsena, of Irasec (Research Institute on Contemporary Southeast Asia), in Singapore. “But the question is not only a matter of accumulating wealth. It has to be equitably distributed.”
The World Bank encourages Laos to rely on its resources, but prudently.
“With appropriate macroeconomic and governance priorities, Laos’ natural resource wealth can contribute to rapid, sustainable growth and poverty reduction,” the bank said in its latest report on the country.
The authorities need to find a way to control investments without closing doors to them. They also need to accept that rapid growth will bring unavoidable changes to society.
While some foreign aid workers romanticize traditional mountain village life in northern Laos, rural people themselves want to see change, said Adrian Schuhbeck, of the German development agency.
“Preservation of traditions should be promoted, but not at the cost of a reasonable access to modern goods for communities in cold mountain areas,” he said. “Polyester blankets coming from China can really improve their life although these are not part of their traditional lifestyle.”